To Sell Or Not To Sell Your Investment Property – Updated

to sell or not to sell

Some Landlords think that if their investment property becomes vacant, it is a good time to sell it.

This view may result from a concern that it may take some time to find a new Tenant and thus there will be a loss of income. Added to this concern is the fact that the rental market can change quickly.


In our experience of over 30 years of Agency Practice, we have seen rents go up as well as go down. Rent prices are all on a cycle and we will see increases in the future when immigration and overseas student intake resume to pre-Covid levels.

We realise that every situation is unique, and this is why it is important to speak with our Team if you are considering a sale – you are welcome to speak to Bec Reid (0410 541 866) or John Pye (0414 914 268) for the best advice.


The below advice is of a general nature; please note it may or may not apply to your circumstances.


If your investment property is VACANT:

  • It is not recommended to have a property listed on both the rental market as well as the sale market, at the same time. It confuses the market and makes both instructions almost impossible to fulfill. It is recommended that you make your choice and move forward with that choice – decide to sell or rent, but not both.
  • If you choose to rent the property again but still intend to sell as soon as the Tenant is found, it is a breach of the Residential Tenancy Act (Section 26) if this fact is not disclosed to your new Tenant. Disclosure of this fact will alarm many prospective Tenants, so it is not recommended to sell once the Tenant is found.
  • If you offer a short-term rental of 6 months or less and you intend to sell the property as a vacant property, it is very difficult to find short-term tenants who we would recommend to a Landlord. In our experience, the vast majority of good Tenants ask for 12-month tenancies.


If your investment property is on a FIXED TERM TENANCY:

  • If the best choice is to sell with an existing tenancy, list your property for sale within 2 or 4 months of the end of any 12-month lease. This then opens the market to both Investors and Owner-Occupiers. The time period of 2 or 4 months is totally dependent on the sale market at the time of listing and the time it is likely to take to find the best Buyer and most of all your needs. Speak to us and we can advise you of the best timing of your sale in relation to the supply and demand in the current sale market.
  • The Tenant may choose to stay until the end of the fixed term or can give us a 14 days notice of termination
  • A Landlord can give a Tenant 30 days’ notice of termination once contracts are exchanged, providing the date is beyond the end of the fixed term
  • If the best choice is to sell as a vacant property, a Landlord can give a Tenant 90 days’ notice of termination providing the date of termination is on or after the end of the fixed term. A Tenant can then choose to end their tenancy at any time.


If your investment property is on a PERIODIC or MONTH-TO-MONTH TENANCY:

  • You can list your property for sale at any time with the tenant still in occupation
  • You can terminate the tenancy with 90 days’ notice at any time if it is preferable to sell as a vacant property.


How to make the best decision – a sale WITH A TENANCY or WITHOUT A TENANCY?

  • Only terminate a Tenant if the Tenant is untidy or if the property requires painting or cleaning to achieve the best price
  • In our experience, vacant properties sell at their highest possible price if professionally styled
  • Tenants enhance a sale price if the Tenant is ‘house proud’ and takes care of the property as if it is their own and they are cooperative in the sale. In these cases, it is highly likely that the sale will be to another Investor who is looking for a good Tenant. This is a win-win for everyone.
  • The market is always better if a property can be offered to both the “Investment Market” as well as the “Owner-Occupier Market”, so be aware of the timing of the sale if currently tenanted.
  • There are many First Home Buyers who buy if they can rent the property to the existing Tenant for a 6 month period before they move in.

Do tenants buy the property they rent?  It is very rare. In over 30 years of our Agency practice, it has happened no more than 2 or 3 times.

Our general advice to Investors is to never sell, as the rents will generally increase over time and the debt goes down and the sale values go up. Our many long-term Investors who bought 15 years ago or more are now receiving 10-25% return on an original investment which is now paid off. Many have now retired and find that their investment provides them with their daily living needs.


Contact us if you have further questions or if you would like to move forward with a sale.

Bec Reid – 0410 541 866 or John Pye – 0414 914 268

Market Appraisal - Sales + Rentals

We would love to hear from you! Please fill out this form and we will get in touch with you shortly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.